I just finished Until dawn and I really enjoyed the game. What I liked a lot is, for example. That the game has a great story, that you can change the story depending on your decision, that you play with a group of teenagers and that it is a horror game.
I would appreciate some good suggestions.
There's nothing similar in this constellation. You can check out a few Quantic Dream games such as Beyond Two Souls, Detroit Become Human
I still thought Detroit Become Human was great.
However, Until dawn was my favorite game from this genre.
Unfortunately nothing comparable with horror elements found so far.
Heavy rain and Beyond: two souls